The Best Cover Versions In The World Ever!

Although I am old and therefore completely out of touch, it does seem to me that a great deal of what passes for new music these days seems to be a load of boring cover versions. The likes of Atomic Kitten and previously Westlife are the worst perpetrators, warming over some dull bygone hit like yesterdays leftovers. It doesn't have to be this way, cover versions can be interesting and innovative. Ideally a cover version should actually improve on the the original rather than just imitate it, here are ten fine examples of how it should be done.

The Stranglers cover Walk On By
Originally by Dionne Warwick

Granted, the extended instrumental workout in the middle goes on a bit but this is a great version of the (pothead granny) Warwick original. Quite heart-rending in its own grubby black t-shirt and naked dancing girls in a cage sort of way.

The Fall cover Lost In Music
Original-ah by Sist-ah Sledge-ah

From the only Fall album I actually legally possess; The Infotainment Scan, comes this surprisingly faithful yet definitely touched by Mark E Smith, cover version. The album also contains a cover version of “I’m Going To Spain”, widely regarded as one of the worst songs ever written. And that is a fact.

Tindersticks cover I’ve Been Loving You Too Long
Originally by Otis Redding

Now, this is more like it, if you are going to a do a cover version then show a bit of class, which the none-more-cool Tindersticks have in spades.
For the last couple of years I have firmly believed that this is just the greatest thing ever. If you have ever been unlucky enough to get a ropey compilation CD from me then this will definitely be on it.
Granted, the singing style is a little less dynamic than Mr Redding, although still great especially for those who appreciate the deeper things in life.
The slow burning soul lament evolves into a huge orchestral refrain with epic strings, plaintive piano, demonic blaring horns and the best drum roll in the entire history of recorded sound. This is what they’ll play at my funeral and I’m already gutted that I won’t be there to hear it.

Tindersticks: coolest band in the world, probably.

Tindersticks: Deep, greatest thing ever.

Pet Shop Boys cover Always On My Mind
Originally by Elvis “Burger King” Presley

Originally done as a bit of a joke for Japanese TV I remember reading somewhere. Shits all over the Elvis original from such a height it isn’t even funny. Sad reminder of how the Pet Shop Boys bestrode the 80’s in huge sounding disco excellence and then went shit. Harsh but true, I’m afraid.

William Shatner covers Rocketman (check it out now)
Originally by Elton John

The former Captain Kirk is a cover version artist of some repute, his versions of Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds and Hey Mr Tambourine Man have moved many to bitter, bitter tears. The Shat connoisseur will point you towards this seminal performance, showcased exclusively at the 1978 Science Fiction Film Awards and actually introduced by the original co-composer Bernie Taupin (a proud moment I am sure).
Shat launches into a disturbing exploration of the true meaning of schizophrenia through the medium of talky, shouty out of tune, Karaoke. And the crowd go wild for the way enunciates “ROCK... ET.... maan” half way through. Truly majestic.

Johnny Cash covers Hurt
Originally by Nine Inch Nails

Really the most disturbing thing ever, a really frail old man singing a really, really sad song full of regret and self loathing. Apparently Trent Reznor was moved to tears when he first heard it, bet he was laughing by the time the fucking royalty cheque appeared.
The way Cash’s ghostly voice floats out of the speakers is really quite unnerving, you have been warned.

Blow My Cool by The Soundtrack Of Our Lives
Originally by The Rolling Stones (sort of)

Not strictly a cover version but essentially the song Let’s Spend the Night Together by the Stones only ten times as good. TSOOL are fairly shameless at this sort of thing but to be honest it’s all great so who cares?

Richard Cheese covers Creep
Originally by Radiohead

Another cover version that improves immeasurably on the original. Richard “Dick” Cheese and his band Lounge Against the Machine treat us to a swing version of this otherwise miserable student, why doesn’t she like me?, standard. Includes weak puns, dangerous whistling and the genius adaptation: “I’m a creep, I’m a nut-job”
Mr Cheese makes a living doing this sort of thing, his Ice Cube covers are particularly affecting.

You will Call Me Kompressor by Kompressor
Originally by Paul Simon

From the freaky world of Mr Steve comes this terrifying 1 minute scuzzfest purporting to be a cover version You Can Call Me Al (you know, the one with Chevy Chase in the video). Something to do with Cabaret Voltaire or something, Don’t ask me, personally I like music that doesn’t make an aneurysm seem like a pleasant alternative. Presumably German.

Nirvana cover The Man Who Sold the World
Originally by David Bowie

From one of those repugnant MTV unplugged things this is a cracking version of one of Bowie’s more intriguing efforts from when he was good. The whole album is a load of cover versions actually, Where Did You Sleep Last Night is excellent too.
Lulu also covered this, in somewhat more bombastic and frankly shit manner, years ago.

 

Comments

1

Also The Wedding Present doing that cockney rebel Make Me Smile thing is good too.

Jim : 04/02/2005 17:45:11

2

Rolf Harris’ version of Stairway To Heaven is cracking.

Keith : 04/02/2005 21:31:38

3

The Slits version of Marvin Gaye’s “I heard it through the grapevine” is a thing of wonder. Especially with Ari Up changing the words at one point to “I heard it through the bassline”.

Also Grace Jones’ dubbed up version of “She’s lost control”, fearsome enough when rendered by Joy Division, but made much more scary by the lanky Russell Harty-abusing model/singer/actress (well, more or less).

Steve : 05/02/2005 23:28:49

4

Oh oh oh - and “Megablast” by Bomb the Bass - basically John Carpenters atmospheric electro theme from “Assault on Precinct 13”, transported from the late seventies to the late eighties, and turned into right-old scratchy hip-hop kickabout. Also the theme to “Xenon 2”, if you were rich enough to own an Atari ST at the time…

Steve : 05/02/2005 23:32:46

5

And there’s more - no matter what the disco freaks will tell you, “Self Control” is much better when done by Laura Branigan, rather than the (presumably Italian?) original by RAF. You’re just going to have to trust me on this. All records at that time absolutely had to go “OH! Ooooh whoh-OH!”, it was the law.

Also the Pet Shop Boys cover (from their apparently “shit” period) of early eighties electro-disco cheesey club thumper “I’m In Love With A Married Man”, originally by Bobby Orlando front Oh Romeo! takes the opposite angle from their uptempo update of “Always on my mind” by slowing it right down, making it unexpectedly lovely in the process.

Steve : 05/02/2005 23:42:40

6

My point? It’s this:

Divine Comedy’s cover of QOTSA’s “No One Knows” is awesome. Saw them do it at V in the summer and have been trying to track down a recording which has proved difficult.

I have read though that it’s being released on their upcoming Bavarian EP. Get it. Go on.

Simon : 09/02/2005 15:15:53

7

I only know of a few of these (Nirvana, Stranglers, Pet Shop Boys) so plenty of stuff to check out - The Fall one especially sound interesting. I’ve compiled my own top 10 list of the best cover versions ever. See what you think..

Ciaran : 29/08/2006 11:15:17

8

Definitely with you on The Specials, Oasis doing I Am The Walrus is probably their finest moment (not saying much these days though is it?)

Jim : 29/08/2006 18:44:12

9

E luogo piacevole, devo dire! Buona fortuna a voi:)

... : 19/12/2006 10:45:17

The Shins cover version of the Postal Service’s We will become Silhouettes is worth mentioning.

sam : 14/01/2008 13:44:52

I absolutely adore Nirvana’s version of The Man Who Sold the World. PSB’s Always on My Mind is excellent as well.

I’d add Chris Cornell’s Billie Jean and Newton Faulkner’s Teardrop.

Cheers, Chev

chev : 05/04/2008 14:11:32

One to consider? - Janis Joplin’s version of Kris Kristofferson’s “Me and Bobby McGee”.

Clive Griffin : 13/07/2008 12:03:42

I would have to say Post Industrial Boys with take a walk on the wild side, original Lou Reed

Manuel : 07/09/2008 01:35:16

Saints - River Deep Mountain High
Aztec Camera - Jump
And Tindersticks - I’ve Been Loving You is indeed fantastic

Jim : 29/07/2009 22:25:53

Without doubt, backing vocalists version
Merry Clayton - Gimme Shelter
Deeper and funkier

don one : 19/10/2010 20:38:36

PSB’s AOMM cover is truly magnificent. I am in love with that version. It is an anthem. And the Boys have not lost all of their excellence. Their last album Yes is truly return to form.

Cenk : 06/09/2011 22:46:20

How’s about:

The Fall - There’s a Ghost in my House (R Dean Taylor)
Stereolab - Theme from Get Carter

James : 03/11/2011 14:07:40

Add your two penn'orth

Categories

Archive

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003